God and Sex
 | This article needs additional citations for verification. (May 2011) |
 | |
| Author | Michael Coogan |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Hachette Book Group |
Published in English | 2010 |
| ISBN | 978-0-446-54525-9 |
God and Sex: What the Bible Really Says is a book by Michael Coogan, published in 2010.[1][2][3]
Content
[edit]Coogan says that in the Hebrew Bible, there is no prohibition of premarital or extramarital sex for men, except for adultery, i.e. having sex with the wife of another man.[4]
Further, he states that premarital sex for women was "discouraged".[4] The Bible has a word for the sons of unmarried women,[4] and their sons were relegated to an inferior social status.[4] He also claims that Paul the Apostle condemned extramarital sex out of apocalyptic fears (he thought that the world was going to end soon)[4] and that Jesus does not say anything about this,[4] except regulating divorce between a man and one of his wives. Coogan uses the singular ("wife"), but does not say that a man could have only one wife, since Jesus was discussing the Law of Moses, which allowed for polygamy.
Interviewed by Time magazine about this book, he also says that words often translated in the Bible as "sodomy" have often nothing to do with anal intercourse between men,[5] and that according to sola scriptura, the Mormons were right about polygamy.[5]
Reception
[edit]The book was well received by Jessica Warner, from the University of Toronto,[1] but was criticized by Prof. Phyllis Trible, from Wake Forest University School of Divinity in North Carolina. Trible asserts that patriarchy was not decreed by God but only described by him, it being specific for humans after the fall, and claims that Saint Paul made the same mistake as Coogan in this respect.[2] The Catholic apologist Robert Sungenis strongly denounced both the book and the author on numerous other grounds.[6]
The book was reviewed by ABC Radio National[7] which claimed that "Michael Coogan is one of the leading Biblical scholars in the US, and in his book God and Sex: What the Bible Really Says, he reveals all, including whether David loved Jonathan in that way."[7]
CNN gave Coogan the chance to present his book on its website.[8] Newsweek also had an article about this book.[9] The Young Turks presented an interview with Coogan upon this book.[10]
Abstract
[edit]The author, Michael Coogan, makes several claims on various issues in his book God and Sex, including:
- that in the Old Testament, child sacrifice was prohibited, but this prohibition wasn't always obeyed;[11] that a man's sexual history was never an issue (thus no such thing as a virginity requirement for men);[12] the only religiously celibate Jews were the Essenes, but this was contrary to mainstream Judaism;[12] Saint Peter was married;[13] Saint Paul thought that Saint Joseph had fathered Jesus;[14] "Joseph 'did not know' Mary 'until she has given birth to a son'" (she did not remain virgin, according to Saint Matthew),[15] prophets were both male and female,[16] the priesthood and the rabbinate were for men only,[17] but Phoebe was a deacon and Junia was an apostle,[18] the Bible states that men are superior to women,[19] polygyny was frequent,[20] abortions were so rare that they were not a problem for the authors of the Bible,[21] but there was a ritual meant for making unfaithful women abort;[22] the books of the Bible were "kind of hypertext",[23] Yahweh visited Abraham,[24] Ishmael has probably sexually abused Isaac;[25] the Bible does not state if Adam and Eve were married;[26] there are Biblical laws regulating polygyny,[27] and "concubine" meant "secondary wife";[28] Abishag laid with David but he was impotent,[29] widows, rape victims and divorced women were "used goods", thus unworthy of a priest;[30] the Bible is inconsistent on divorce[31] and "pervasively patriarchal";[32] the Ten Commandments were intended for Jewish men only;[33] marriage meant transfer of property,[33] but women were inferior to real estate;[33] adultery was about property rights;[34] in the Hebrew Bible there was no ban on men having sex with unmarried women (including prostitutes);[34] in David's time Jerusalem had only a few thousand inhabitants;[35] father-daughter incest was only a devaluation of daughter's value;[36] Onan was not masturbating;[37] the Bible is inconsistent about brother-sister incest;[38] sex with a woman was prohibited during her period,[39] but so is wearing wool and linen;[40] David and Jonathan were not sexual partners;[41] Sodom's sin was being inhospitable to strangers[42] and "mistreatment of the powerless";[43] Saint Jude does not say that Sodom's sin was homosexuality;[44] "sacred prostitution" nowhere and "never took place";[44] the Hebrew Bible does not say anything about lesbianism,[45] but Saint Paul thought that God made homosexuals so;[46] Jesus said very little about sexuality;[47] the Bible is opposed to homosexuality;[48] having sex with prostitutes was seen as a way of losing money[49] and Saint Paul opposed the use of prostitutes,[50] but "Judah's use of a prostitute was normal and acceptable",[49] this also applies to Samson,[51] who also foreshadowed suicide bombers;[51] Mary Magdalene wasn't a prostitute;[52] God has reproductive organs[53] and had a wife/wives;[54] Jews were initially polytheist,[55] Genesis 1:26-27 says that the elohim were male and female[56] and humans were made in their image;[57] God's sons had sex with women;[58] Yahweh is a sexual being,[59] Wisdom was God's wife,[60] gods used to have children in many mythologies,[61] Israel was God's wife[62] (polygyny wasn't a problem for him);[63] "all theology is metaphor"[64] and Yahweh was "an insanely jealous and abusive husband".[64]
Those are some of the issues up through page 188 of the book.
Bibliography
[edit]Coogan, Michael (October 2010). God and Sex: What the Bible Really Says (1st ed.). New York, Boston: Twelve. Hachette Book Group. ISBN 978-0-446-54525-9. OCLC 505927356. Retrieved May 5, 2011.
References
[edit]- ^ a b Jessica Warner "Sex and the biblical scholar", The Globe and Mail, 14 December 2010.
- ^ a b Phyllis Trible, "God and Sex: What the Bible Really Says" Archived 2012-08-06 at the Wayback Machine, Biblical Archaeology Review, 20 January 2012.
- ^ "New Book by Professor Michael Coogan Examines Sex in the Bible", Stonehill College, 29 September 2010, new URL: archive dot today/BOYC Archived 28 November 2010 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ a b c d e f 5 Questions with Professor Michael D. Coogan Archived 2011-09-19 at the Wayback Machine The Summit, 19 October 19 2010. New URL: http://admin2.collegepublisher.com/se/the-summit/opinion/5-questions-with-professor-michael-d-coogan-1.1716380 Archived 2011-09-19 at the Wayback Machine . Quote: "In ancient Israel, premarital sex by a woman was discouraged because in the patriarchal society of that time, a daughter was her father's property. If she was not a virgin her value--the bride price her father would get from a prospective husband--was diminished. Also, any child born to an unmarried woman would be fatherless--the Biblical term is "orphan"-- and so without either a male protector or any possibility of an inheritance, which was passed from father to son. There is no explicit prohibition in the Old Testament of premarital or extramarital sex by men except for adultery, which meant having sex with another man's wife."
- ^ a b Alexandra Silver What the Bible Has to Say About Sex Time.com, 31 October 2010
- ^ Robert Sungenis, Sr., PhD Book Review of: God and Sex: What the Bible Really Says[dead link], Culture Wars, January 2013.
- ^ a b Rachael Kohn The World's Sexiest Book. The Spirit of Things. ABC Radio National, 15 January 2012.
- ^ Michael Coogan Bible has some shocking 'family values' CNN.com, 26 October 2010.
- ^ Lisa Miller, What the Bible Really Says About Sex, Newsweek, 6 February 2011
- ^ The Young Turks 21 December 2010.
- ^ Coogan (2010:31)
- ^ a b Coogan (2010:33)
- ^ Coogan (2010:36)
- ^ Coogan (2010:38)
- ^ Coogan (2010:39)
- ^ Coogan (2010:43)
- ^ Coogan (2010:48)
- ^ Coogan (2010:49)
- ^ Coogan (2010:59)
- ^ Coogan (2010:63)
- ^ Coogan (2010:64)
- ^ Coogan (2010:66)
- ^ Coogan (2010:73)
- ^ Coogan (2010:75)
- ^ Coogan (2010:77)
- ^ Coogan (2010:78)
- ^ Coogan (2010:79)
- ^ Coogan (2010:80)
- ^ Coogan (2010:81)
- ^ Coogan (2010:88)
- ^ Coogan (2010:89)
- ^ Coogan (2010:98)
- ^ a b c Coogan (2010:102)
- ^ a b Coogan (2010:103)
- ^ Coogan (2010:105)
- ^ Coogan (2010:109)
- ^ Coogan (2010:110)
- ^ Coogan (2010:111)
- ^ Coogan (2010:115)
- ^ Coogan (2010:117)
- ^ Coogan (2010:121)
- ^ Coogan (2010:124)
- ^ Coogan (2010:130)
- ^ a b Coogan (2010:133)
- ^ Coogan (2010:135)
- ^ Coogan (2010:138)
- ^ Coogan (2010:139)
- ^ Coogan (2010:140)
- ^ a b Coogan (2010:153)
- ^ Coogan (2010:152)
- ^ a b Coogan (2010:157)
- ^ Coogan (2010:159)
- ^ Coogan (2010:163)
- ^ Coogan (2010:167)
- ^ Coogan (2010:170)
- ^ Coogan (2010:175)
- ^ Coogan (2010:176)
- ^ Coogan (2010:177)
- ^ Coogan (2010:178)
- ^ Coogan (2010:179)
- ^ Coogan (2010:180)
- ^ Coogan (2010:182)
- ^ Coogan (2010:184)
- ^ a b Coogan (2010:188)